Want to instigate a heated discussion with athletes? Just ask them their preference of peanut butter -- crunchy or smooth? To help celebrate National Peanut Butter Day on January 24, we posed this question to a wide range of stars including Pro Football Hall of Famers Eric Dickerson, Derrick Brooks and Tim Brown, Panthers quarterback Cam Newton and softball icon Jennie Finch.

Related Story: Liquid Meatballs? Yep, And Here's How To Make Them